Skip to Main Content

New Nursing Guide

Writing Literature Reviews

What is a Literature Review?

The Literature review is a vital part of the research process.  You will gain important insights, knowledge, and awareness; you are setting the stage for a better-designed study and can improve your chances of obtaining significant results.  Therefore, it is worth the time and effort to do it right!

Reviewing the literature involves:

  • locating
  • analyzing
  • synthesizing
  • interpreting

previous research and documents (periodicals, books, abstracts, etc.) related to your study area.

A thorough and intensive review of the literature enables you to do the following:

  1. Focus the purpose of your study more precisely;
  2. Develop a conceptual or theoretical framework that might be used to guide your research;
  3. Identify key variables for study and suggest relationships among them if you are completing a quantitative study.  If you are conducting a qualitative study, identify the concepts and topics you plan to study;
  4. Uncover previous research similar to your own that can be meaningfully extended;
  5. Determine the relationship of your topic relative to current and past studies;
  6. Form a basis for determining the significance of your study;
  7. Uncover questionnaires or tests previously validated (please see Measurement and Evaluation tab of this research guide for more on this);
  8. Link your findings to previous studies.  Do your findings support or contradict them?

The Literature review can be organized in a number of formats.  Three of the most common are:

  1. Historical Format -- Where the review is organized chronologically.  This is preferred when focus is on the progression of research methods or theories, or a change in practice over time. 
  2. Conceptual Format -- Review is organized according to relevant concepts and/or theories.
  3. Methodological Format -- Where literature review structure mimics that of an empirical paper (introduction, method, results, etc.).  Most often used in meta-analytic reports. 

Define and Refine Your Topic

  • Choose a research topic of interest; think critically (and creatively about it); can you contribute new knowledge/research about this topic?
  • Start a general review (browse key texts on the topic, reference works, journals, websites)
  • Identify the major ideas/issues/researchers
  • Define the time period (i.e., how far back do you need to search the literature)
  • Formulate keywords = main concepts and related terms (use thesauri, subject headings, etc.)
  • Craft search statements for databases and online catalogs such as CONSULS (utilize Boolean operators, truncation, parentheses, proximity operators, phrase searching using quotes); record your methods
  • Narrow or broaden your topic as appropriate based on literature search results

Search All Relevant Sources Comprehensively & Efficiently

  • Journal article and dissertation databases -- find citations of articles/dissertations and full text of articles/dissertations.
  • Bibliographies - from relevant journal articles, books, etc. (cycle backwards in time)
  • Citation indexes -- e.g. Web of Knowledge/Social Sciences Citation Index (SSCI); Education Research Complete on Ebsco; Google Scholar (cycle forwards in time by identifying citing articles; find the most cited articles on your topic)
  • Current awareness sources:
    • Identify & browse current issues of the most relevant journals for your topic
    • Set up alerts (email, RSS), journal tables of contents; indexes; websites
    • Grants databases
    • Web discussion groups, listservs, blogs, etc.
  • Book catalogs (find books, government docs, internet resources, audio-visual media, theses/dissertations)
    • CONSULS; other libraries and library systems, i.e., Worldcat; Google Books, Yale's Orbis catalog
    • Individual specialized library catalogs via the Web
  • Web search engines (Google, Infomine, etc.) and digital repositories, general and specialized
  • Experts (scholars, expert practitioners, librarians, etc.)
  • Literature guides (founds in books and in databases, library/academic guides and pathfinders)

Find & Evaluate & Manage the Information

  • Analyze your database search results (citations) & revise/improve your search statement (find the best balance/tradeoff between comprehensiveness and precision)
  • Understand the scholarly/scientific research & peer review publication process
  • Evaluate the type of information found and its relevance to your topic (determine the source; credentials of the author; objectivity, accuracy, currency, etc.)
  • Retrieve the information source from the database or library or Interlibrary loan/document delivery
  • Critically read and analyze articles; review methods, data, statistics, etc.
  • Gather, store, and annotate relevant citations (e.g., Endnote Web, Zotero, Mendeley)

Synthesize the Literature and Integrate it into Your Writing

  • Choose the appropriate type and style of publication/presentation
  • Move back and forth between writing and further literature research

 

Note: this guide was adapted from Barry Brown's Outline for Comprehensive Science Literature Review, published on the Web and found at: http://www.lib.umt.edu/files/ComprSciLitSearch2012.pdf.  Mr. Brown is a librarian at the University of Montana's Mansfield Library.

Examples and Tips About Literature Reviews

Scholarly & Popular Literature on Creating a Literature Review